Skip to main content

Pourquoi J'Aime 'Les Amants'


It has Jeanne Moreau.

It has the most exquisite andante from Brahms String Sextet.

It has extended sequences that involve both Jeanne Moreau and the (exquisite) andante from Brahms string sextet.

It is directed by one of the most fabulous French film makers, Louis Malle, and probably ranks alongside Smiles Of A Summer Night as amongst the most swooning meditations on romantic love (albeit on this occasion without Russian roulette).

Did I mention, it has Jeanne Moreau.



It has a sequence in which a very a la mode Parisienne wakes up with a groomed daschund already in the crook of her arm.

It has the most extraordinary sequence of laughter in any film in which the laughter is both such a release and a realisation of how much laughter has simply been missing for so long that it is delirious and painful in equal measure.

It is a beautifully observed portrait of Paris and the provinces with all the droll superficiality that implies.

But above all it is the utterly rhapsodic and all encompassing sequence when the lovers wander at night from the well tended parterre into the wild garden (in a way that Andrew Marvell would have recognised and applauded) that elevates this beyond being a simply fine film into something quite extraordinary.



In her white nightdress and flowing hair, Jeanne is back to a wildness rather than the primped and pristine figure of the first hour of the film.

The lovers free fish trapped in a cage by Jeanne's husband as they cross a stream before gliding without oars on a boat across the lake because 'there's no resisting happiness'.

And it's that sense of complete mutual submission and lack of constraint that is captured so perfectly by Malle and which goes into complete overdrive with the extraordinarily well matched Brahms which in itself can create a knee tremor at fifty paces.

The tropes of folk tales involving lovers meeting at night are then completed by the cockerel crowing in the dawn. At this point the lover should either vanish or, if you're particularly unlucky, turn out to have been dead all along.

In this case neither. Instead there is a wonderfully observed sequence in which love and doubt intermingle as the mundane and the quotidian intervene to ever greater extent.

And the beauty of it is that Malle is sufficiently brave to end the film by showing both. Akin to The Dolls House, Jeanne may go, and she may well go alone, but that delirious night is the experience - for which she has absolutely no regret - that allows her to do so.

Some audiences at the time (1958) were scandalised. Now all we see is the most delirious account of two people meeting and saying to each other: 'I've known you forever'.


Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Best (and Worst) Films of 2023

  One of the most joyful rediscoveries this year was Percy Adlon's  Bagdad Cafe  which in a wonderfully surreal manner captures the magic, literal and figurative, that a most unlikely outsider brings to the moribund, allowing them to realise what they have been missing through their obsessive introspection and to grow through the recognition of the value in difference. Could there possibly be a message in there? In the 'they do still make'em like that' category the outstanding example was the  The Three Musketeers: D'Artagnan  which was pure pleasure from the tip of its épée to the handle of its poignard, running full tilt with the ridiculousness of the plot half way round France and back across the Channel without pausing for breath. Hats are worn with an angle of jaunt worthy of an Expressionist noir, swords are barely ever in a scabbard, panelling is chewed liberally and Eva Green's use of her belle poitrine auditions it for separate billing in the cast list.

There are worse things than cows on the line

A new explanation for the delay to my train this afternoon: cows on the line. This did, however, provide some time to reflect on other rather more serious characteristics of modern life than the inconvenience occasioned by the peregrinations of the odd Friesan.  So here are six which seem to me to be particularly pernicious aspects of our current situation.  1.  Libertarianism : otherwise known as letting me do whatever I want and a plague on everyone else. Such a convenient doctrine for the already powerful and utterly malign as a philosophy for the common good with a resolution to remove everything that might be a constraint or require a contribution to the commonweal. This is wholly distinct from liberalism and indeed individualism which are both important and positive. The basic issues that libertarianism always avoid are that a free for all never serves those without agency. The deep structural imbalances in society that fuel inequality have to be collectively addressed

Museum Hours

A new blog which fittingly has a first post about the  film  which provided the inspiration; a quite wonderful, wry look at a few days in the life of a museum attendant in Vienna. There have presumably been easier pitches in the history of cinema but we should be deeply grateful that this gently subversive piece made it through. For this is a film that shouts quietly. About the way that we all too easily jump to conclusions about people based on what they look like and what they do; indeed how in a gallery we ignore or look down on the watchers without reflecting that they may be rather more acute in their observation of us. Our attendant relatively early lets slip that he spent much of his former life on the road with rock groups and in one particularly droll moment slightly hesitantly announces to an amused Mary Margaret O'Hara that he does still like heavy metal whilst looking as though he would be considerably more likely to put on a CD of Mantovani. About the way that w